The Blue-Eyed Crab Caribbean Grill & Rum Bar Reviews & Menu

General Info

If you are looking for a waterfront dining experience in Plymouth, The Blue-Eyed Crab Caribbean Grill & Rum Bar at 170 Water St, Plymouth, MA 02360, is a restaurant that offers a relaxed atmosphere paired with a menu that appeals to a wide range of tastes. From casual lunches to leisurely brunch outings and evening gatherings, this spot creates an inviting setting for both locals and visitors exploring the area.

One of the first things that stands out is the variety found on the menu. Guests often appreciate classic favorites such as the Burger, which delivers a satisfying and hearty meal, while seafood lovers can enjoy options like Fish and Chips and fresh Oyster selections. The Clam Chowder is another notable menu item, offering a comforting choice that fits naturally with the coastal character of the location. The menu balances familiar comfort food with flavors that encourage diners to slow down and enjoy the experience.

The atmosphere feels welcoming and social, making it a comfortable choice for groups. Whether stopping by with friends, family, or colleagues, the dining room provides a casual environment where conversations flow easily. During my visit, the combination of waterfront surroundings and attentive service contributed to a pleasant overall experience without feeling rushed.

Brunch is another appealing reason to visit. The restaurant offers a relaxed setting where guests can settle in and enjoy a slower pace, making it a suitable destination for weekend meetups. Alongside the food offerings, cocktails play an important role in the experience. A refreshing Margarita pairs well with many menu items and adds an extra layer of enjoyment to the meal. The bar program complements the restaurant’s identity while providing options for those looking to unwind.

Convenience is another advantage. The restaurant offers dine-in service, allowing guests to fully enjoy the atmosphere, and the availability of a free parking lot makes visiting easier, especially during busy periods. For travelers exploring Plymouth’s waterfront locations, this added convenience can make a noticeable difference.

Reviews frequently highlight the enjoyable combination of food, drinks, and atmosphere. The restaurant’s location near the water enhances the overall dining experience, while the diverse menu gives visitors multiple reasons to return and try something different. Whether enjoying a bowl of Clam Chowder, sharing Oysters with friends, ordering Fish and Chips, or sipping a Margarita during brunch, The Blue-Eyed Crab Caribbean Grill & Rum Bar provides a memorable restaurant experience that blends comfort, flavor, and a welcoming social setting.

What customers say?

“ A little hidden gem! familiar with Plymouth, we finally made a big move in our lives and moved to Plymouth, Massachusetts, from New Jersey in recent months. We dine out frequently, and are so happy to share great places like the Blue Eyed Crab. This place is a GEM! The atmosphere is fun, the music is great and not in your face loud but by far the food is outstanding! Our appetizer was the crab dip with fresh baked chips with a little spice, that was delicious, my husband ordered the jerk chicken, and excellent best he ever had, I ordered the seafood stew and again, incredibly delicious with fresh and chunks of seafood with fresh flavors. We were so happy to find such a great restaurant a rare event from soup to nuts! ”

- Maria Olivieri -

“ In the midst of a ginormous life, there lay a destination that begged for me to reawaken my senses. As soon as I saw the word "Caribbean" on the sign, I knew it was high time to find delight in the brilliance of a world I had yet to touch. Once I saw the acrylic mural on the wall, showing the archetypal Caribbean landscape flourishing on the cusp of midday and dusk, I knew the place had found a convincing identity. In understanding this, I didn't want to skimp on cultural favorites. I stuck with apps, figuring it might be the bee's knees without getting too elaborate. The peanut starter, first off, knew it was aiming for more than elephants. Its gentle brush of spice stood mighty on a cliff, perfectly conveying the restaurant's tropical atmosphere. Each bite made a familiar flavor melt in my mouth like I hadn't experienced anywhere else. The jibarito, a sandwich served between two enormous fried plantain slices, was also worth the wait. Having the Atlantic Ocean sit outside your window is one thing, it's better to see it while you experience the crunch of the plantain and a variety of umami flavors dancing across your tongue. It wasn't ashamed to flash its ballgown crystals, and I respected this dish for it. While the wait for our main dishes took longer than we preferred, the day worked out and the artists showed us their best work. Thank you, crew, for transforming my day into a waltz of dreams! ”

- Samuel Freitas -

“ I love going to this place every time I come back to my home town. The food is shears fresh and delicious and it’s my go to on the water front, if you want to be on the water, those places may lack in food quality as they are all touristy. Amazing Caribbean flair food with fresh seafood and rice bowls. They have an outdoor patio fir people watching too. We got the swordfish with a mango salsa and the shrimp and chicken rice bowl—everything was so flavorful. The crab bisque was delicious, despite the lack of crab in it. ”

- Shadia d -

Welcome to The Blue-Eyed Crab Caribbean Grill & Rum Bar

General Info

The Blue-Eyed Crab Caribbean Grill & Rum Bar menu

The Blue-Eyed Crab Caribbean Grill & Rum Bar Photos

What customers say?

Location & Contact

See more food places